Gay Fire Island Restaurants

Cherry's on the Bay serves elevated comfort food with a creative twist, making it a popular dining spot in Cherry Grove. The LGBTQ+ friendly restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere and a menu featuring fresh seafood, seasonal ingredients, and decadent desserts. Perfect for a casual meal or a romantic dinner with that special someone.

Island Breeze is a lively beachfront bar and restaurant serving up delicious American cuisine and refreshing cocktails. Known for its laid-back vibe and LGBTQ+ inclusive spirit, this spot is perfect for casual dining or sunset drinks with friends. Highlights include fresh seafood, burgers, and tropical-themed drinks. It's an ideal place for a laidback meal with a drink or two.

Pines Bistro & Martini Bar offers a sophisticated dining experience with a menu of Italian-inspired dishes and expertly crafted martinis. This LGBTQ+ favorite in Fire Island Pines is perfect for an elegant night out, featuring intimate seating, warm hospitality, and mouthwatering pasta and seafood options. It's the perfect place to sip cocktails in a relaxed but elegant setting.

Located in the heart of Cherry Grove, Canteen is a casual eatery serving comfort food classics in a relaxed setting. Perfect for a quick bite, the menu features sandwiches, salads, and daily specials made with fresh ingredients. Its inclusive atmosphere makes it a favorite stop for locals and visitors alike. It's the ideal place for casual eats.